[Aida2024] Closing
Ulises Cortés
ia at cs.upc.edu
Tue Aug 19 15:59:03 CEST 2025
Dear Sylwia /et al/
/
/
Now more committee sent their votes. Dr. Jannik Peters still the /most
voted candidate./ I will wait to the end of the week to see if there are
more votes (and changes).
Best
u
> Dear All,
>
> As a simple measure, I also did a calculation that does not just sum
> the votes but counts the sum as proportion of all votes obtained by a
> given dissertation. Jannik Peters came to 0.6, Thomas Fel to 0.44.
> While I personally prefer the latter to the former, numbers are what
> they are. The results may change if more people cast their votes.
>
> Best,
>
> Sylwia
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
> *From:* Ulises Cortes via Aida2024 <aida2024 at eurai.org>
> *Sent:* Sunday, August 17, 2025 10:28 AM
> *To:* aida2024 at eurai.org <aida2024 at eurai.org>
> *Subject:* Re: [Aida2024] Closing
> *External email to Cardiff University - *Take care when
> replying/opening attachments or links.
> *Nid ebost mewnol o Brifysgol Caerdydd yw hwn - * Cymerwch ofal wrth
> ateb/agor atodiadau neu ddolenni.
>
>
>
> Good morning Henrique
>> Dear Ulises,
>>
>> I am unsure about the procedure that is being followed to award the
>> prize.
>> I assumed that at this stage each of us was supposed to analyse all 6
>> applications.
> The basic assumption is that each of us analyse /at least/ three, some
> of us did more. Also trying to have mos t of the thesis with at least
> three opinions. For a few candidates I asked for external iad.
>> However, looking at the Excel, it does not seem everyone is doing so.
> detto
>>
>> If you compare Jannik Peters and Thomas Fel, considering only the
>> jury members who have assessed both, there seems to be a tie.
> This morning, I detected the issues and I am reviewing both (again).
>> How fair is the process if we allow some of us to overlook some of
>> the applications? (To a lesser extent, I had the same kind of doubts
>> regarding the previous stage, I should say.)
>
> So far, we have no decision. If the tie persist we will focus on those
> and, maybe, have a winner and a forerunner.
>
> If you like, I will be happy to have short call with you, just let me
> know.
>
> have a nice Sunday
>
> u
>
>>
>> Best,
>>
>> Henrique
>>
>>
>> On Sat, Aug 16, 2025 at 6:49 AM Ulises Cortés via Aida2024
>> <aida2024 at eurai.org <mailto:aida2024 at eurai.org>> wrote:
>>
>> Dear Committee members,
>> We are almost there, but we are still waiting for a few members'
>> answers. Let us wait a few more days, I will not be back in the
>> office
>> until next 19/8.
>>
>> As of today, we have a candidate, Jannik Peters, with five (5) votes.
>>
>> If you have any comments, please let me know.
>>
>> Have a nice weekend
>>
>> u
>>
>> --
>> I work strange hours, so you might receive emails from me at
>> unusual times -
>> please don't feel any obligation to reply right away if this
>> arrives outside your normal working hours.
>> --
>> Prof. Ulises Cortés
>> CS - Computer Science Department CS- Computer Science
>> Department
>> Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya UPC Barcelona
>> Supercomputing Center
>> c/Jordi Girona, 1 & 3, Plaça Eusebi Guell, 4
>> Edifici OMEGA 205 Edifici Repsol, 4th Floor
>> 08034 BCN, Catalonia, Spain 08034 BCN, Catalonia, Spain
>> voice: +34-934137842
>> fax: +34-934137960
>> Webpage:
>> https://track.pstmrk.it/3t/www.cs.upc.es%2F%7Eia/tSbS/-mO-AQ/Ag/90774ea3-064e-400d-a14a-05a7cd120c63/4/DSajqrLkLz
>> <https://track.pstmrk.it/3s/track.pstmrk.it%2F3s%2Ftrack.pstmrk.it%252F3s%252Ftrack.pstmrk.it%25252F3t%25252Fwww.cs.upc.es%2525252F%2525257Eia%25252FtSbS%25252F-mO-AQ%25252FAg%25252F90774ea3-064e-400d-a14a-05a7cd120c63%25252F4%25252FDSajqrLkLz%252FtSbS%252FYWq-AQ%252FAQ%252F6d02b047-6ced-4d15-a19f-b748b4273d06%252F1%252FTEd8mHZLtm%2FtSbS%2FeWq-AQ%2FAg%2F7a26e2ae-7032-43b3-aa4a-c14c619d0801%2F9%2FmHa31fAMzr/tSbS/WnC-AQ/AQ/3f00eb57-4490-4fb7-b4e5-c8c9c35dccf1/1/lHHkvkOgHO>
>> https://track.pstmrk.it/3ts/www.bsc.es%2Fcortes-ulises/tSbS/-mO-AQ/Ag/90774ea3-064e-400d-a14a-05a7cd120c63/5/SbNAjyHsp1
>> <https://track.pstmrk.it/3s/track.pstmrk.it%2F3s%2Ftrack.pstmrk.it%252F3s%252Ftrack.pstmrk.it%25252F3ts%25252Fwww.bsc.es%2525252Fcortes-ulises%25252FtSbS%25252F-mO-AQ%25252FAg%25252F90774ea3-064e-400d-a14a-05a7cd120c63%25252F5%25252FSbNAjyHsp1%252FtSbS%252FYWq-AQ%252FAQ%252F6d02b047-6ced-4d15-a19f-b748b4273d06%252F2%252Fp-jFYR3i9Z%2FtSbS%2FeWq-AQ%2FAg%2F7a26e2ae-7032-43b3-aa4a-c14c619d0801%2F10%2FVPj7i88F56/tSbS/WnC-AQ/AQ/3f00eb57-4490-4fb7-b4e5-c8c9c35dccf1/2/sPF850pXKX>
>> Email: ia at cs.upc.es <mailto:ia at cs.upc.es>
>>
>> --
>> Aida2024 mailing list
>> Aida2024 at eurai.org <mailto:Aida2024 at eurai.org>
>> https://track.pstmrk.it/3t/mail.eurai.org%2Fcgi-bin%2Fmailman%2Flistinfo%2Faida2024/tSbS/-mO-AQ/Ag/90774ea3-064e-400d-a14a-05a7cd120c63/6/Fe0AhazOzk
>> <https://track.pstmrk.it/3s/track.pstmrk.it%2F3s%2Ftrack.pstmrk.it%252F3s%252Ftrack.pstmrk.it%25252F3t%25252Fmail.eurai.org%2525252Fcgi-bin%2525252Fmailman%2525252Flistinfo%2525252Faida2024%25252FtSbS%25252F-mO-AQ%25252FAg%25252F90774ea3-064e-400d-a14a-05a7cd120c63%25252F6%25252FFe0AhazOzk%252FtSbS%252FYWq-AQ%252FAQ%252F6d02b047-6ced-4d15-a19f-b748b4273d06%252F3%252FSCTH7rE283%2FtSbS%2FeWq-AQ%2FAg%2F7a26e2ae-7032-43b3-aa4a-c14c619d0801%2F11%2FuwYqXgzF7a/tSbS/WnC-AQ/AQ/3f00eb57-4490-4fb7-b4e5-c8c9c35dccf1/3/u4boDdIO-D>
>>
>
> --
> I work strange hours, so you might receive emails from me at unusual times -
> please don't feel any obligation to reply right away if this arrives outside your normal working hours.
> --
> Prof. Ulises Cortés
> CS - Computer Science Department CS- Computer Science Department
> Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya UPC Barcelona Supercomputing Center
> c/Jordi Girona, 1 & 3, Plaça Eusebi Guell, 4
> Edifici OMEGA 205 Edifici Repsol, 4th Floor
> 08034 BCN, Catalonia, Spain 08034 BCN, Catalonia, Spain
> voice: +34-934137842
> fax: +34-934137960
> Webpage:http://www.cs.upc.es/~ia <https://track.pstmrk.it/3s/track.pstmrk.it%2F3%2Fwww.cs.upc.es%252F%7Eia%2FtSbS%2FeWq-AQ%2FAg%2F7a26e2ae-7032-43b3-aa4a-c14c619d0801%2F12%2FQYHpebfV23/tSbS/WnC-AQ/AQ/3f00eb57-4490-4fb7-b4e5-c8c9c35dccf1/4/Am4JRxtGc8> https://www.bsc.es/cortes-ulises <https://track.pstmrk.it/3s/track.pstmrk.it%2F3s%2Fwww.bsc.es%252Fcortes-ulises%2FtSbS%2FeWq-AQ%2FAg%2F7a26e2ae-7032-43b3-aa4a-c14c619d0801%2F13%2FDLPrFg7Pqv/tSbS/WnC-AQ/AQ/3f00eb57-4490-4fb7-b4e5-c8c9c35dccf1/5/VNODRPX4-f>
> Email:ia at cs.upc.es <mailto:ia at cs.upc.es>
--
I work strange hours, so you might receive emails from me at unusual times -
please don't feel any obligation to reply right away if this arrives outside your normal working hours.
--
Prof. Ulises Cortés
CS - Computer Science Department CS- Computer Science Department
Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya UPC Barcelona Supercomputing Center
c/Jordi Girona, 1 & 3, Plaça Eusebi Guell, 4
Edifici OMEGA 205 Edifici Repsol, 4th Floor
08034 BCN, Catalonia, Spain 08034 BCN, Catalonia, Spain
voice: +34-934137842
fax: +34-934137960
Webpage:http://www.cs.upc.es/~ia https://www.bsc.es/cortes-ulises
Email:ia at cs.upc.es
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mail.eurai.org/pipermail/aida2024/attachments/20250819/165acfe5/attachment.htm>
More information about the Aida2024
mailing list